Italian restaurants

Nicolino's Restaurant

4.4 732 reviews Closed 4515 NY-30, Amsterdam, NY 12010, United States

Discover this place

Nicolino's Restaurant, nestled at 4515 NY-30 in Amsterdam, NY, has quickly become a cherished gem among Italian dining enthusiasts. Known for its warm atmosphere and attentive service, Nicolino's offers an array of mouthwatering dishes that leave patrons eager for their next visit.

Highlights include the bistro calamari and fried mozzarella, which set a delightful stage for entrees like the delmonico steak and gorgonzola chicken Cavalli. Customers rave about the generous portion sizes, often leaving with leftovers—something to look forward to after a satisfying meal. The homemade lasagna and gnocchi Bolognese consistently receive praise for their rich flavors and comforting qualities.

The restaurant's ambiance adds to its charm, with many reviews mentioning the inviting decor—a perfect backdrop for a special date night or a casual gathering with friends. The cocktails also deserve a mention, with guests describing them as “crazy good.” Overall, Nicolino's strives for culinary excellence paired with exceptional service, making it a must-visit destination in the 518 region.

Photos

Amenities & More

Service options

Onsite services
Takeout
Dine-in

Highlights

Fireplace
Great beer selection
Great cocktails
Great coffee
Great dessert
Great wine list
Serves local specialty

Popular for

Lunch
Dinner
Solo dining

Dining options

Lunch
Dinner
Catering
Dessert
Seating
Table service

Amenities

Bar onsite
Restroom
Wi-Fi

Atmosphere

Casual
Cozy
Quiet
Romantic
Trendy
Upscale

Crowd

Family-friendly
Groups
Tourists

Note: Amenity details are aggregated from verified visits, the venue's website and Google. They may change without notice. We recommend confirming key details (pet policy, accessibility, reservations) directly with Nicolino's Restaurant before visiting.

Reviews for Nicolino's Restaurant

4.4

732 reviews

100%

22%

Review highlights

Based on 732 reviews

Nicolino's Restaurant consistently receives praise for its generous portion sizes and flavorful dishes, making it a popular choice for both Italian and New American cuisine enthusiasts. Reviewers frequently highlight the attentive and personable service, which enhances the overall dining experience. The menu offers a range of well-prepared items, including seafood, steaks, and classic appetizers, all noted for their quality and taste. Many guests appreciate the inviting atmosphere and view Nicolino's as an ideal spot for casual dining and special occasions alike. Overall, the restaurant is recognized for delivering excellent value, combining delicious food with friendly service in a welcoming setting.

Kayleigh Denney

Jul 31, 2025

Perfect date night! Nicole was our waitress and she was AWESOME! So personable and fun. We ordered the bistro calamari, fried mozzarella, chicken francaise, and delmonico steak. Everything was delicious! The portion sizes were perfect- love going home with leftovers! Caesar salad and chowder were great too. We are excited to go back!

Bea Taylor

Jun 22, 2025

We happen to stop by on Saturday June 1st. We had amazing waitress. I order the gorgonzola chicken Cavalli it's was a huge portions. Everyone at our table were very happy and we all took leftovers home & dessert. We look forward to returning

Andy Britton

Jun 12, 2025

The food is exquisitely delicious, and I love the inside of the place

Joseph Giardino

May 25, 2025

Amazing meal , very attentive staff, crazy good cocktails A+++

Juliana Barlop

May 18, 2025

Love it here! Food and service is always phenomenal. The portions are amazing and definitely get what you’re paying for. Decent pricing alongside amazing food. Definitely recommend this place one of the best in the 518!!!

Jennifer Cammarata

May 06, 2025

Just tried Nicolino's tonight with my husband and brother in law and we were all impressed with the food and service. Jocelyn was an excellent server. We put our entire order in at once including drinks, appetizer, soup/salad, and our meals, and Jocelyn made sure everything came out staggered. The portions were huge and our meals were freshly made and piping hot. Excellent choice if you're in the mood for Italian food!